Every dollar counts in today’s competitive climate, and knowing what and when to measure can determine a startup’s success. Vanity metrics are outdated as investors, teams, and customers seek substantial signals. The positive side? You only need to track essential metrics.
Startups often erroneously view KPIs as mere checkboxes, but successful companies see them as forward-focused tools. What distinguishes a valuable KPI from a vanity one? Effective metrics directly connect to behavior, focus, and value.
Focus your KPIs on your current stage, not future aspirations. Early-stage founders sometimes mistakenly measure success like Series C companies, discussing CAC without consistent acquisition or emphasizing LTV before proving retention. It’s akin to prioritizing fuel efficiency without a complete car.
Consider Superhuman: they famously delayed launching until they reached a 40% Product-Market Fit (PMF) score, asking users: “How would you feel if you could not use this product?” When 40% said “Very disappointed,” the company moved forward. This single qualitative KPI helped guide their strategy and maintain discipline pre-scale.
At Zing Coach, grouping metrics into Health, Growth, and Signal categories proves helpful. Health metrics like LTV:CAC, crash-free sessions, cash flow balance track business stability. Growth metrics like user retention, feature adoption, or workout completions measure progress and evolution. Signal metrics, such as total MAU or lifetime usage, share Zing’s narrative externally. Each tier effectively serves different purposes when emphasized intentionally.
The key takeaway? Match the metric to the moment. In the early stages, qualitative signals like user satisfaction, NPS, and product engagement often provide more value than revenue or user numbers.
Prioritize leading indicators over lagging ones. Revenue and churn are important but lagging indicators. Headline figures, often beloved by investors, are backward-looking. Instead, track what initiates those outcomes.
If you have a B2B SaaS tool and notice users activating three features in the first week have a 70% higher retention rate, you’ve identified a leading KPI. It shifts the focus to: How many users activate three features within a week? This becomes a North Star for your team, influencing everything from onboarding to product design to support strategy. Teams excel when aligning and sharing ideal outcomes.
Notion, for instance, views activation as a critical KPI. Their teams track how quickly new users discover “aha” moments, like creating their first document or sharing a workspace, as these predict long-term engagement better than user count.
Ensure KPIs are actionable, not merely admirable. A strong KPI directs behavior. If it’s interesting but doesn’t influence operations, it’s a distraction.
Chilli Piper, in the meeting lifecycle space, noticed “meetings booked” didn’t correlate well with pipeline conversion, but “meetings held within 48 hours” did. This slight measurement adjustment transformed sales operations and significantly improved conversion rates.
You don’t need an extensive data science team to spot patterns. Often, the most valuable KPIs are obvious but require asking: What specific behavior do we want to drive? What’s the clearest proxy? From there, narrow your dashboard to a few high-impact metrics for each team. Assign each a responsible party, a timeframe, and actionable levers. What about other numbers? Use them for internal decisions but keep the top view clear. Strategy should be precise, not cluttered.
Don’t track metrics you’re not ready to act on. Despite the temptation (especially with advanced analytics stacks) to measure everything—session duration, bounce rate, click-throughs, scroll depth, time to first response, and so on—only use metrics for which you drive change.
One founder had a sophisticated real-time KPI dashboard with 30+ metrics. When asked which three they discussed at Monday meetings, the answer was “Honestly… mostly revenue and MRR.” The rest? Just data wallpaper.
A better approach: select 3 to 5 meaningful metrics per team, review them weekly, and support them with team-controlled levers. Anything else distracts. Don’t fear shifting focus; if growth stalls or you encounter product bugs, temporarily focus on Health metrics. If stable, invest in growth. To build buzz or validate demand, concentrate on Signal metrics. Mix them purposefully, not by default.
Your KPIs narrate a story, so ensure it’s the right one. Metrics go beyond internal use—they shape external perception. Investors, journalists, and potential hires assess your numbers to gauge momentum.
Consider the rise of “efficiency metrics” in 2023 and 2024. With tighter capital, VCs scrutinized the Burn Multiple (spend to generate a dollar of net new ARR) and Magic Number (efficiency in converting sales/marketing spend into revenue). Startups adapting their metrics to demonstrate sustainable (not just raw) growth experienced improved fundraising dialogues.
Ramp